RubiStar

Rubric Made Using:

RubiStar ( http://rubistar.4teachers.org )

>> To save this document onto your computer, please choose File :: Save As from your Browser Menu.

CATEGORY

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Satisfactory

Facts

Commentary clearly and logically defines or clarifies facts objectively.

Commentary adequately defines or clarifies facts objectively.

Commentary generally defines or clarifies facts objectively. May not be adequately supported.

Commentary does not adequately define or clarify facts objectively. Minimal support.

Values (Professional Code)

Identifies choices and ethical options (balance). Makes appropriate and powerful connections to issue.

Identifies choices and ethical options but not all may be relevant to contribute powerful connections to issue.

Identifies a choice or ethical option. The information is appropriate to the issue.

Information struggles to relate to a choice or ethical option.

Principles

States principles and clearly explains how they underlie our options (balance). Makes appropriate and powerful connections to issue.

Response clearly states principles. Makes appropriate and powerful connection to issue.

Response states principles but the choice is a somewhat general connection to issue.

Response struggles to relate to a principle. Makes vague or little connection to issue.

Loyalties

Provides a robust and accurate summary of loyalties.

Provides an effective summary of loyalties.

Not a comprehensive summary of loyalties. Some important stakeholders are left out.

Numerous important stakeholders are omitted.

Summary

Arranges ideas clearly and logically; achieves balance to support the purpose or argument.

Arranges ideas adequately to support the purpose or argument.

Arranges ideas that generally support the purpose or argument.

Arranges ideas but frequently fail to make sense together to support the purpose or argument.

Class Participation

Notes from discussion are comprehensive and show collaboration.

Notes from discussion capture many important topics as part of collaboration.

Notes from discussion capture some of the topics that resulted from collaboration.

Collaboration effort is satisfactory. Notes do not include all important topics.

blank

 

 

 

 

Mechanics

No grammatical, spelling, or punctuation errors. Document layout instructions followed.

Almost no grammatical, spelling or punctuation errors, or error with layout.

Several distracting grammatical, spelling, or punctuation errors. Errors in document layout.

More than 5 spelling, grammatical or punctuation errors. Interferes with understanding report. Errors in document layout.